top of page

Temenos AG's Alleged Financial Scandal and Activists' Support

a stock price chart for Temenos AG, with a significant drop in the share price around 19th February 2024

A few days ago, Temenos AG, a Swiss-based banking software company, found itself at the center of a major financial controversy following allegations made by Hindenburg Research.


These allegations included accusations of accounting irregularities, manipulated earnings, and major operational inefficiencies.



The Temenos Scandal: Allegations and Responses


Key Allegations


Hindenburg Research's Report: Hindenburg Research, known for its investigative financial research, released a report alleging financial irregularities within Temenos. The allegations suggested manipulated earnings, accounting irregularities, and operational inefficiencies. Hindenburg claimed its investigation involved interviews with 25 former employees and an analysis of the company's financial practices.


The key points raised include:


  • Alleged Financial Manipulations: The report points to evidence suggesting Temenos engaged in practices such as round-tripping revenue, establishing sham partnerships, pulling forward contract renewals, backdating contracts, and excessively capitalizing R&D investments, which are considered signs of accounting irregularities.


  • Questionable Practices by Leadership: The investigation claims these aggressive accounting practices were known among many former employees, with some alleging encouragement from CEO Andreas Andreades to use these methods to mask customer dissatisfaction and attrition.


  • Strategic Partnerships Under Scrutiny: A specific case mentioned involves a partnership with fintech company Mbanq, announced by Temenos as a move to accelerate banking-as-a-service adoption in the U.S. However, allegations suggest Temenos funded the purchase of its software through an undisclosed investment in Mbanq, implying a potential roundtripping scheme.


  • Partnership Failures: Another partnership with DXC Technology, which was intended to be strategic, reportedly ended in termination due to lack of action from Temenos, resulting in a significant financial write-off for DXC.


  • Pulling Forward of License Renewals: The report includes statements from former employees about the practice of pulling forward license renewals, often at discounts, to boost short-term earnings at the expense of future revenue.


  • Backdating Contracts: There are allegations of Temenos backdating contracts to earlier quarters, a practice reportedly known and condoned by top management but denied publicly.


  • R&D Spending Misclassification: Hindenburg Research suggests that Temenos' reported R&D investments might be inflated, with claims that many of these investments were actually customer-specific implementation costs misrepresented as R&D.


  • Challenges in Revenue Collection: The investigation highlights Temenos' Days Sales Outstanding (DSO) as nearly double that of its closest peers, suggesting aggressive revenue recognition policies and challenges in collecting reported revenue.



Temenos' Response to Hindenburg Research Report


Temenos AG has issued a strong rebuttal to the allegations presented by Hindenburg Research in a recent report. According to Temenos, the report is plagued with factual inaccuracies, analytical errors, and false claims aimed at negatively affecting the company's share price.


Notably, Temenos highlighted that Hindenburg Research did not seek any comment from them before publishing the report, which raises questions about the research's thoroughness and objectivity.



Key Points from Temenos' Official Statement


  • Refutation of Allegations: Temenos' Board of Directors categorically denies the contents of the Hindenburg Research report, emphasizing that it contains misleading allegations designed to harm the company's market valuation.


  • Financial Health and Performance: Temenos reassures its stakeholders about the robustness of its business operations, financial health, and strong cash position, indicating that the company stands on solid ground despite the allegations.


  • Independent Investigation: Temenos announced plans for an independent investigation into Hindenburg's allegations. The company's non-executive chairman, Thibault de Tersant, expressed optimism about Temenos's financial controls and the solidity of the company, suggesting that the investigation would clarify the situation and reassure stakeholders.



Market Reaction and Activist Investors' Support


Share Price Impact: Following the publication of Hindenburg's report, Temenos's share price experienced a significant drop, around 26% - from 88.62 CHF on 14/02 to 60.60 CHF on 16/02, reflecting the market's immediate reaction to the allegations. This downturn highlighted the substantial impact of short-seller reports on market perceptions and investor confidence.


Activist Investors and Stock Movements: In the wake of these allegations, activist investors such as Petrus Advisers and Sparta Capital Management reportedly increased their stakes in Temenos, betting on the company's ability to weather the storm and recover. These movements indicate a divided opinion among investors regarding the validity of the allegations and the company's prospects.


Calls for Leadership Changes: Amidst the controversy, there were calls from certain investors, including Petrus Advisers, for significant changes in Temenos's leadership, specifically targeting the removal of interim CEO Andreas Andreades. These calls were partly based on the belief that leadership changes were necessary to restore investor confidence and correct alleged operational inefficiencies.



The situation surrounding Temenos AG remains fluid, with ongoing debates about the company's financial practices, leadership, and future direction. The upcoming independent review and its findings are likely to be pivotal in resolving the current controversies and shaping the company's path forward.


As the Temenos scandal continues to unfold, the financial community awaits the results of independent investigations and the potential long-term effects on Temenos AG's reputation and operations.


Click Here to access Hindenburg Research's Findings.



 

Join our ESG Community Forum — a hub for collaboration and innovation in sustainability. Share knowledge, exchange best practices, and drive impactful change.

 

Subscribe to be a catalyst for a responsible business future.

 



Comments


Subscribe to our newsletter  Don’t miss out!

Thanks for subscribing!

a black board with letters community

Building Bridges, Not Walls, for Global Unity

Explore ESGinie

ChatGPT

Your AI Sustainability Assistant

esgchatgpt
bottom of page